Tuesday, April 13, 2010

From the perspective of infinity, it matters not in what order I eat my ritual breakfast, only that it has these things: a priobiotic supplement, a glass of cranberry juice, a cup of kefir, a couple of soft-boiled eggs and an espresso.

The probiotic is to digest any wheat that I might consume. The cranberry juice is to control undesired bacteria in my digestive and urinary tracts and on my skin. The kefir is to build my constitution, both adding flora and digesting the milk it is in, which like the eggs is good for protein. The yolks, in particular, taste good, but they add to the buildup in my gall bladder which is cleared by the espresso. The espresso brings awakening, focus, clarity of thought, and bowel movements.

It all gets mixed up in my stomach anyway.

From the perspective of infinity, the order of most things doesn't matter. It doesn't matter that I had children first, and a loving relationship after. It doesn't matter that my younger brother died first. Sometimes I see a young man walking down the street who looks like him and then I remember that he would have been in his mid thirties by now. Before long, my sons will be the age he was when he died.

Certain things, you would think, have to be built from the bottom up. Like houses. But then you see the Americans hoisting up a house from its foundations and adding a first story down below, and it makes you wonder about all the other normal-looking two-story homes on the street.

Samuel Johnson said that it matters not how you die but how you live, because the act of dying lasts so short a time.

I was with my brother when he died, and I'm not sure if dying is an act. He had been intubated and tranquilized. I was holding his hand. The machine indicated that his heart had stopped pumping but the nurse had to come in and turn off the ventilator.

We were surprised by all the young people who came to his funeral.

My father used to say that those who eat alone die alone. I don't know if he was alone when he died. He too had been on a life support machine, but when I last saw him he was breathing naturally, while remaining in a vegetative state. This is not to say there weren't bouts of self-propelled movement, almost like a fugue state, including vocalizations and tearing of the eyes. But when I left him he looked somewhere between life and death. The word "goses" came into my mind, a Hebrew word for this limbo state that has no equivalent in English. It could be either a verb or a noun, like the Hebrew word "met" meaning "a corpse" or "he died". He died about a week later.

I had a chance to remediate those experiences by being at my grandmother’s deathbed. She was always a difficult woman, but she had lost the ability to speak, and in many ways this made things easier for her caregivers. We knew it was serious and came when we heard she had punched the orderly in the face who was trying to feed her. I took turns with my mother, sitting by her bedside, as my grandmother, like my brother, was dying of pneumonia. This time, thankfully, there was no talk of adding a ventilator or heroic measures to keep her alive. After two weeks, it was a Sunday when she was evidently about to pass away. The nurse had ordered morphine, but in the UK a doctor had to be called from another hospital to sign for it. My grandmother was evidently in a lot of pain, although she was unable to use her voice to communicate it, doubly silenced by pain and brain injury.

Finally, the doctor arrived, and I went to my grandmother, holding her hand and making eye-contact to comfort her, and said, “The doctor is here, he can give you something to help with the pain.” I tucked her blanket and went to close the door, so she would not overhear the doctor and my mother talking in the corridor outside. By the time I got back to the bed, my grandmother had lost consciousness and never regained it. The doctor examined her and the morphine was added to her drip while my mother and I continued to sit with her, prayer book ready. But it was the gentleness of that last caring communication with my grandmother which I felt transcended my ordinary experiences, in a way that informs my work with patients in pain.

Is the moment of death itself of any significance? A patient once said she did not wish to die alone, and when asked she explained that what she meant was she wanted family and familiars to care for her in her final illness.

Proverbs enrich the meaning of life notwithstanding their contradictions. We are what we eat, and we are not what we eat. The clothes make the man, and not the clothes make the man. It matters only that you love. Be happy while you're living, for you're a long time dead. But when you're dead, who are you? Are you the same person as before you were born? Is there even a you outside the boundary moments of birth and death? And what about the periods of time near those edges, when the I is forming or falling apart? Or even between those times? I like the way T. S. Eliot expressed this in The Four Quartets: "You are not the same people who left the station, or who will arrive at any terminus".

From the perspective of infinity it matters not if I lived at all. But some things do matter, and I would like to figure out and tell others what they are.

2 comments:

  1. "I would like to figure out what really matters. For me, that means figuring out how to live, or what is good."

    these are such important ideas, as we can be troubled by self-doubt when we examine how we live and our thoughts.
    How do you prove, is it required to prove a person's ethical/philosophical framework for life?
    Some things give the mind great pleasure and can torment as well, beyond mediocrity and how others think and live often.

    I came back the other day to re-think Pierre Bourdieau,"Distinction"and still think it so remarkable a book. On one hand it explains many facets of aesthetics and how it operates, de-mystifying the process but then it is very much about the whole notion of class and inequality.

    For me i take a delight in ideas and beauty , this is what keeps me going , my day at work is filled with ideas i do not share with those around me as i work, i see the world of ideas as the constant companion.
    The creative aspect is driving force in human progress and yet society battles against every minute of the day.
    This is the greatest pity of life that we encounter i feel, that all human progress is in spite of the difficulties.

    Pursig did not say anything that i did not feel or know in particular but i felt it was wonderful that these ideas were expressed publicly and may have influenced people .
    These ideas are like a light or beacon perhaps in that we know we are not alone in our thinking.

    Pedro

    ReplyDelete
  2. What a shame this breathed for but a moment.

    ReplyDelete